The Choice Theory concept is very practical to implement in schools, although there are some limitations to the theory.
- Dr. Glasser believes that all mental illnesses or diseases outlined in the DSM-IV-TR are as a result of an individual’s brain ‘creatively expressing its unhappiness’ (Glasser, 1998). It is irrational of Dr. Glasser to postulate that their is no such thing as mental illness (White, 2005). It is of concern that Glasser refers to all medications as “brain drugs” and at times compares them to poison (White, 2005).
- For Choice Theory to be effective it must be applied across the whole school. If teachers are time poor or the Choice Theory conflicts with their individual pedagogy, the Choice Theory will be ineffective and confuse students (Lyons et.al, 2011). To implement it seamlessly it must be a school-wide initiative.
- Jay Weinstein also raises the point that students behaviour is likely to be affected by other factors such as the group dynamic; behaviour is unlikely to be solely dependent on student needs (Weinstein, 2000). Students often alter their behaviour depending on the size group and the dynamics of the group.
- The final criticism of the Choice Theory is that a conflict in ideas exists between the fact that a student purposefully chooses total behaviour but doesn’t use behaviour to control or express individual perceptions (Bourbon, 1994).
Although the theory has been met with criticism it should not be discounted to the point that it isn’t applied. The criticisms point out that when applying this model in schools, care must be taken to ensure it is a school-wide approach, all teachers are on board and have the time to attend to students needs, and teachers are leaders as apposed to bosses in the classroom (Lyons et.al, 2011).
Glasser, W. (1998b). Choice Theory in The Classroom (rev ed.) New York: Harper Collins.
White, C. (2005). Warning: Psychiatry Can Be Hazardous to Your Mental Health. Prim Care Companion J Clin Psychiatry, 7(2): 76
Lyons, G., Ford, M., Arthur-Kelly, M. (2011). Classroom Management: Creating Positive Learning Environments. South Melbourne, Australia: Cengage Learning
Weinstein, Jay. (2000). The Place of Theory in Applied Sociology: A Reflection. Theory and Science. 1, 1.
Bourbon, W. Thomas and Ford, Ed. (1994) Discipline at Home and at School. Brandt: New York.

